Introduction
In this essay, I explore the following questions: Why do many humans like fuzz even though it can be so abrasive and violent sounding? Why do others dislike it? Why is it so polarizing?
To answer these questions, I consider fuzz in its physical and even metaphysical forms, I consider the difference in its affect on audiences that enjoy it and those that do not, and I consider its impact and reception in society. By the end of this exploration, we will see that fuzz’s impact is explained by the following properties. Fuzz is: 1) authentically totally broken; 2) metastable; 3) fundamentally other; 4) maverick (i.e., resists being owned by humans); 5) iconoclastic.
Physics of Fuzz
Physically, to our ears, fuzz is obviously just sound waves, moving through the air at specific frequencies. It is usually played with an electric guitar or bass, each of which have their own timbres or sonic qualities, and then those are passed to the fuzz that adds its own layers on top, before reaching the amplifier. The texture of the fuzz sound is a hard and compressed distortion, very rich in harmonics. There are many different variations of fuzz, but these properties are arguably the most common across all varieties.
Fuzz sounds like this because of its circuitry. Again, there are many kinds of fuzz: console, fuzz face, tone benders, zonks, octave up/down, big muffs, etc.; it is a diverse branch of analog guitar effects. For my purposes, even severely overdriven amps with slashed speaker cones count as fuzz. Each of these have their own circuitry, and some topologies are very different from each other. For example, fuzz faces and tone benders are relatively close cousins, but two EMI Redd 47 mic preamps stacked into each other to produce the Beatles’ “Revolution” tone obviously have a different and more complex combined topology. The Shin-Ei FY-2 has, in my opinion, the most elegant and beautiful fuzz topology (I will do a full article on this circuit one day), closer to a Mosrite Fuzzrite, and these are different topologies again from a console fuzz or a classic fuzz face variant. Though there are many different technical ways to achieve the fuzz sound, the sound itself has some commonalities. It is a broken square wave created by amplifying the signal past the linear operation of the amplifier and its power supply (i.e., the signal hits the power rails, not usually diodes in fuzz), and this creates a theoretically infinite set of harmonics which sound very compressed and tonally smeared.
Diodes versus Rail Clipping
To appreciate the difference between distortion caused by transistor rail clipping vs. diodes, and the corresponding difference in harmonic smearing vs. moderate distortion of the fundamental frequency of a note played, we need to go a little deeper into what is happening to the wave form. Distortion caused by diodes (whether hard or soft clipping configurations) is softer than distortion caused by transistor (e.g., BJT) rail clipping, which means it sounds a little lighter and technically it is the product of an artificially broken sound. Distortion is artificial in this case because the engine of the amplification itself is not necessarily distorting, but rather the signal is being run through a local part of the circuit that has a very narrow voltage range (caused by the forward voltage drop of the diodes). Diodes themselves do not turn off and on as cleanly as a BJT because they have something called a knee (a measure of how instantaneous the clipping is) which is much softer than a BJT’s. This makes it artificially broken in my opinion. I contrast this with the authentic brokenness of a fuzz circuit where it is the amplification engine itself which is responsible for the distortion and the resulting square wave is extreme. Now, immediately there will be some objections from octave pedals or the Big Muff Pi. With the Big Muff Pi for example, there are soft clipping diodes in the negative feedback loops of two internal gain stages, but in fact at the second feedback stage, the signal is already so overdriven that the soft clipping diodes in it lose their softness and become basically indistinguishable from a fuzz square wave. This circuit is also arguably thought of more as a distortion pedal, not a pure fuzz, even though it uses soft clipping. It is easy to get embroiled in irrelevant debates about this sort of thing but suffice to say it pushes soft clipping to the point of becoming formally indistinguishable from a hard clipping transistor, so I think of it as a fuzz.
Another important difference to note is that when the amplification engine itself clips, especially when multiple engines clip in some circuits, the distortion is not limited to one local section of the circuit as is the case with diodes, because “engine clipping” involves all other components in the surrounding nodes of the circuit. For example, a clipping BJT can easily partially drain a large capacitor in the circuit because it is working so hard in amplifying and the capacitor’s charge cannot keep up with momentary demands of playing. This effect adds a “sag”, or delay, in saturation, because every strike of the string(s) drains the capacitor so it must fill up again before the transistor can use it to re-bias itself. Similar things happen in a tube amp’s power supply. Diode clipping on the other hand is not a function of the engine’s work, so it won’t drain the capacitor in the same way and the playing dynamics remain more stable and in some ways less responsive. To be clear, I am not saying diode clipping is aesthetically worse or better than rail clipping, I just want to clarify the formal differences between them to advance the investigation of fuzz itself. So, the first difference between the brokenness of engine clipping is authenticity, and the second difference is the totality of the distortion within the circuit’s architecture.
Harmonic Smearing in Fuzz
Any kind of distortion or clipping generates harmonics. The AC guitar signal swings up and down in the the form of a sine wave. If one side is limited more than the other, such that either the peaks lose their top or the valleys lose their bottom, then we have asymmetrical clipping. If both sides lose their tops and bottoms at the same time to the same degree, then we have symmetrical clipping. Asymmetrical clipping creates more even order harmonics: 2, 4, 6, etc. Symmetrical clipping creates odd order harmonics: 3, 5, 7, etc. Now, what happens in fuzz is that, because the clipping is so aggressive and created by the interaction of the whole circuit, the distortion produces extreme harmonic content, symmetrical and asymmetrical even mixing in the same circuit depending on how the transistors are biased. When an overdrive or distortion pedal clips, lots of harmonic content is created but it stays relatively linear by comparison, and the original fundamental note can still be heard. When fuzz clips, there is so much harmonic content that it obscures the fundamental, and the harmonics themselves take over the signal, competing with each other to be amplified.
Competing harmonics have a name: Intermodulation Distortion (IMD). The frequency of the fundamental and the harmonics subtract from and multiply each other as the note rings, leaving the remainder and product frequencies louder than the others in amplification. This happens in a semi-random fashion as the note’s attack ascends and decays, and different frequencies rise and collapse on themselves. The result is an unresolved mess that happens to sound beautiful to some people (and distasteful to others). This harmonic smearing is what lets us call fuzz metastable, where one harmonic frequency is as likely as another to succeed in getting amplified. This is also why fuzz can sound like so many other instruments to some extent: a violin (á la Eric Johnson), a cello, a trumpet, a saxophone. The first fuzz, the 1962 Maestro FZ-1 Fuzz Tone, was actually marketed to guitarists as a tool to let them achieve the timbre of a horn player. Timbre is just a function of different harmonic profiles. The timbre of each instrument is what accounts for that instrument’s unique sonic identity, why a sax sounds like a sax. By returning the signal to a state of unresolved harmonics, fuzz unlocks a pre-individuated sonic potential that recalls a number of different possible sounds. It is embryonic sound that hasn’t chosen a specific form yet. Diode distortion, whether hard or soft, whether symmetrical or asymmetrical, never quite gets that wild.
Now that we have an understanding of what is happening physically with the sound of fuzz, we are able to get into some metaphysics.
Metaphysics of Fuzz
A musician expresses sound in musical ways, and there are some philosophers who thought sound was a metaphysical force, something that desired to express itself even before musicians existed. Gilles Deleuze was one such philosopher, and we are going to apply some of his concepts to our findings so far, in order to learn more about why audiences and musicians react how they do to fuzz. If we asked him, Deleuze might have said sound as a metaphysical force is “Voice.” It is a part of life as evolution’s work of infusing matter with indeterminacy and creativity (a line he got from Henri Bergson). Sound becomes expressive in animals: birds, cricket legs, humans, etc. In humans, Voice found a creature that could express better than anything else on earth, and humans channeled it into all sorts of instruments and different kinds of music. These are beautiful things in culture, but in the process of Voice expressing itself through humans, after the initial genesis of music, the musical forms start to get generic and imitative. This is certainly true in effects pedals, where names like Tubescreamer show how derivative the sound becomes. In guitar, at first sound expressed itself in a resonator (acoustically), then it became amplified, and then overdriven, but in all these cultural evolutionary steps, Voice is only expressed insofar as it is useful to human cultural growth and endurance. It is not allowed to express itself without control as it might like. What would that sound like? White noise, all the frequencies at once. But that doesn’t make for conventionally accepted music. Nevertheless, when fuzz returns sound to a preformed state of inter-modulated harmonic combat, it is closer to white noise than overdrive or clean guitar sounds, and therefore we can say that fuzz is closer to metaphysical Voice sounding for itself than other musical effects.
Fuzz as a Tool to Defeat Cliché
This means that fuzz is fundamentally other, not a mere human artifact. For artists, this is actually quite interesting and useful. Paradoxically, the fact that it is form-obliterating means it can be used by artists to make their own forms more aesthetically appealing. Deleuze, in his work on painter Francis Bacon, talks about a technique artists have available to them called the Diagram. The Diagram is a randomizing mark or colour that saves a painting from being cliché. As an artist, whether painter or musician, the blank canvas or silent studio room is actually already full of clichés, all the possible shapes and colours and sounds that are already canon. What a tool like the Diagram can do, is restore some chaos and indeterminacy to the artwork that can make it new and aesthetically interesting and pleasing again, despite all the other more conventional content that is in there. In music, I think of the one or two flat notes played with rubato at times in the opening melody of Ravel’s Adagio Assai (in E major) of the Second Piano Concerto in G major: they provide just enough dissonance to save the piece from being too predictable. Likewise I suggest that fuzz can be used as the timbre (or “anti-timbre” if you will) to make even monotone drone guitar sounds beautiful to listen to: one’s ears can just lean in to the single tone creating all that harmonically unstable content, just barely hanging on throughout the repetitive attack and decay of the obliterated fundamental. Cinnamon Girl by Neil Young for example (i.e., the solo) is an excellent example of this I think. The work is dramatic and sometimes bludgeoning in fuzz and feedback, but somehow stays beautiful and powerful in such songs, despite the overt simplicity of the melodies played. The power these guitar tones have is metaphysical Voice.
Fuzz Against Humans
If we consider some other annoying things about fuzz, the argument that fuzz is less about human cultural utility and more about Voice sounding for itself becomes even more convincing. Fuzz is designed to be first in the signal chain because the input impedance is horribly mismatched for guitar pickup output impedance. Fuzzes, especially germanium transistor fuzzes, are prone to temperature related bias drift. Fuzz often needs reverse polarity power supplies if not using batteries because PNP transistors of older effect units are not compatible with modern centre-negative power supplies. When playing a fuzz pedal, one cannot really make complicated chords because there is too much dissonance due to all the conflicting harmonic content, so it forces a musician to play more melody or only simple chordal ideas. Limitations and challenges define the use of a fuzz, and therefore it is arguably the most misanthropic effect. I think this feature hits on the first polarizing aspect of fuzz: it is maverick. Some people will like this and some people won’t, and it depends a lot on what you feel your music needs as an artist. But this feature of fuzz resisting human domination, its insistence on being difficult and reckoned with, certainly can explain why some people like it and others do not. For those that don’t, they are probably interested in other more mimetic guitar effects (e.g., Tubescreamer), or perhaps just enamoured of the guitar as a mechanical resonator -- that’s fine. For those that do love it, there is something else going on too. It is called the sublime.
Fuzz and the Sublime
Edmund Burke, and later Immanuel Kant, developed this idea of the sublime in order to explain an aesthetic experience where we are at once drawn and somehow repulsed by the same stimuli. This deep vibrating ambivalence is pleasurable because it sets up a feedback loop between the object (or music), and the faculties of imagination and reason in our mind. There are two kinds of sublime and fuzz engages both of them. The first is called the dynamic sublime, or natural sublime as I think of it. We experience it when we are beside a great natural force which impresses and even scares us a little, but one which does not ultimately affect us. Think of standing beside a waterfall for example. It is exhilarating because we feel the power, but we know how predictable its limits are, so we are safe as long as we obey the rules we have learnt from our parents about standing too close to waterfalls.
The second form of the sublime is called mathematical by Kant and we experience it when we expose ourselves to something that is so immense and infinite that we feel puny in comparison (e.g., the visually uncountable stars in the sky). This confrontation with our own perceptual finitude is offensive to the ego in some respects, but the fact that we can think of the infinite extent or intensity of the thing stimulating us is satisfying because we at least appreciate its hugeness rationally with our minds. Other creatures (Kant thought) do not have access to this rational knowledge of infinities, so it is very satisfying to humans to use this unique faculty.
Fuzz gives us the dynamic sublime when we are listening to it tear our guitar signal to pieces, sounding like something is violently breaking, yet we know it is just an effect that won’t hurt us. Fuzz gives us the mathematical sublime when we sense the source of those inter-modulating conflicts, an infinite of frequencies living in the white noise of metaphysical forces. I think it is the sublime which helps those who like fuzz to stay enthusiastic and motivated enough to use it despite all the resistance it puts up to human domination.
The Power of Fuzz in the Individual and Society
There are some interesting implications of our investigation of fuzz for the individual and society. For the individual, fuzz can be a wonderful reminder that we don’t have to play the same thing over and over again, or that even if we do, it can be rendered new again with the unique messy tones of fuzz. I think there is another power of fuzz for the individual here too, apart from just playing different music. When we play music, for many of us, we are doing something extra for ourselves, outside of our identities as an employee or even as a child or parent. Playing fuzz, something that refuses to fit in 100% within the framework of timbre or music, can remind us that we ourselves have an outside or eclipsed identity, wonderfully useless to anything and anyone else in our lives. I think when we play fuzz, in all its unpredictable unresolved harmonics, we are reminded that we too can return to a preformed state of life if we really wanted to, at least in music if not in any other dimension of life (i.e., I am not necessarily recommending any fuzz-inspired mid-life crises or run-away-from home scenarios). Remembering this can be very empowering.
For society, the stakes for returning to a different possible political or economic form are obviously a lot higher: so much structure is at stake, history, culture itself. Small wonder, then, to think of the reception of Link Wray’s “Rumble.” It is no accident that it remains the only instrumental song banned on American radio. Authorities knew at an instinctual level the metaphysical source of the music was chaos, and it scared them. They didn’t want it to catch a fire with the youth and spread. They didn’t want revolution. It seems ridiculous in some ways: how could a farty, lo-fi, broken guitar sound be so threatening? It’s because fuzz is a felt biological connection to life as an evolutionary force. Ridiculous as it might sound, fuzz as evolution is scary, iconoclastic. We know what happened to the dinosaurs -- no one likes to think of themselves and their way of life as fragile, contingent, and perhaps sometimes in need of drastic moral reform. But it’s still good that fuzz is there to remind us of these truths.
Conclusion
Fuzz’s properties of being broken, metastable, other, maverick, and iconoclastic, are what make it political and uncontrollable, and ultimately valuable, both to the individual and society. It is easy to think of art as excessive, frivolous, and useless, but what fuzz shows is that art’s power is absolutely revolutionary and necessary. It has the power to help each of us question ourselves and grow. By being its inimitable self, fuzz makes us feel the persistent possibility of change in our lives, both individually and collectively, and that is wonderfully hopeful.
Oddly enough, fuzz can only do this if it resists us, if we are forced to respect it. This is cultural proof that dominion is boring. Uniformity is boring. That being said, fuzz is often used sparingly in songs, usually just for the solo. Too much of it fatigues the ears. Too much change all the time is not a good thing, not for music, and probably not for individuals or society, like living in white noise or total anarchy. One can enjoy fuzz and appreciate its sublime beauty without living in a constant state of anarchic revolution. But fuzz stays there, waiting for us quietly on our pedal boards, ready for times when we do need the reminder and courage to act for change. Fuzz is a little like Excalibur: we have to be worthy and overcome its resistance, and it’s not for everyday cheese-slicing, but when we really need it, nothing (in timbre) works better to awaken the hero in us and others.
Joseph Sneep is the designer and maker of innovative analog guitar effects at Antifōn Audio, in Toronto, Ontario, Canada.

