Introduction
In the guitar pedal world, the difference between the analog and the digital is often cast as being diametric, but I have always felt this is misleading. It is misleading because both technologies are simply seeking to shape someone’s musical idea (e.g., a melody, song, etc.), so they actually run together, serving the same purpose. While there is overlap of capability, each also has unique and independent properties and abilities, which is important to remember because it shows the two are not really in competition, but rather just two possible ways of getting some musical thing done.
Joshua Heath Scott from JHS Pedals recently wrote an interesting article talking about how John Mayer has finally recognized the improved quality of digital models of his analog rig. Some guitarists will read Josh’s article and feel like the romantic force of analog effects has lost its greatest warrior, “analog Achilles”, by John Mayer finally recognizing digital’s progress, as if analog is “losing” now. In this article, I want to show how this is not something to worry about, even if you are an analog monogamist, because:
1) Analog and digital processes usually have different moments in the evolution of musical tools (and in their adoption by sound-tinkering guitarists), and they are already used together all the time, so their relationship tends to be sequential or summing, not canceling;
2) Within the history of analog effects itself, purely analog technologies have succeeded each other to no catastrophic effect on music making (e.g., tubes to transistors to ICs);
3) The line between analog and digital technology blurs in some cases (in fact, some of your favourite effects already do this and it is a necessary and wonderful thing that they do so);
4) There is still lots to investigate and invent in analog music effects so nothing is really “ending”.
Before all that though, I think it is worth contextualizing analog and digital technology in some (hopefully) more accessible technical detail. This will help show how, far from being two armies on opposing sides of an arbitrary cultural battlefield, they are just different and complementary tools peacefully coexisting in the artifactual economy of us lucky modern musicians.
Does “Informational Integrity” Make Analog Better?
In the context of guitar pedals and many other musical effects, analog technology essentially refers to tools that take an input from an instrument or microphone and translate it to an output without losing any information: the transfer function between source and output is theoretically pure or “isomorphic” as engineers like to say. Isomorphic is a big word but it just means a difference at the input (e.g., you slide your finger up one guitar fret) gets to make an equal physical difference at the output (e.g., that exact physical moment of changing pitch is amplified). By contrast, a digital tool takes an input, samples the signal at a certain rate, changes its form into discrete bits of memory, processes those bits, and then reconstitutes it at the output to the desired effect. The digital process is similar to how, in math, you may try to describe a movement by connecting points on a graph (i.e., interpolation), but add as many points as you like, you will always be creating new lines between them, so you never really perfectly describe the original curve: something was lost in translation, even if there are so many points that your eye doesn’t see the difference any more. I think this inherent digital loss and analog integrity is (perhaps more or less consciously) the source of the analog monogamist’s self-righteous superiority. Though at first “informational integrity” may seem good for analog monogamists, practical applications of technology complicate the value of definitions.
Valuing analog over digital based purely on technical definitions and specifically “informational integrity” does not make much sense because analog guitar pedal effects morph the signal in every stage of a circuit, from the input section, to EQ intermediary sections, to the output, and even the power supply design: all those components and design blocks affect frequency response. Guitar pick-ups are inductors which can make resonant filters when their signals are amplified. This means they may ring out harshly, often requiring designers to heavily low-pass the signal, dumping a lot of information to ground, before and/or after amplifying it. Many famous guitar amplifiers have an always-on mid-scoop baked into their EQ precisely to mitigate this issue. Other analog circuits suffer from the opposite problem: many fuzzes for example don’t provide enough input resistance (i.e., impedance (Z)) to the guitar signal which inadvertently dampens it, resulting in treble loss. I could go on but you get the point: if informational integrity is what makes analog preferable then the analog monogamist has to explain why their information losses are better than digital losses. Maybe analog losses are, by design, more musical, whereas digital losses are so distracting and ugly because they are unintentional and obtrusive?
Do Indiscernible Informational Differences Matter?
Digital losses can sound bad and, in older versions of digital technologies, these artifacts could definitely be unpleasant enough to complain about. Digital losses include:
1) Sample Rate Inadequacies: if the sample rate frequency is not a little more than twice as fast as the input frequency, you get something called “aliasing” and you violate something else called the “Nyquist limit.” This means you lose information and that loss results in unpleasant extra artifacts at lower audible frequencies. Interestingly, this is why standard digital recording sampling is set to values like 48kHz, since human hearing does not go above 20kHz.
2) Bit Depth Inadequacies: the analog signal is digitally captured at a certain resolution of numerical detail so an amplitude measurement with 5 decimal places of precision will be more accurate than 1 decimal place. By rounding less between data points, the 5 decimal point recording will be “truer” to the source while the 1 decimal point recording will have a higher “quantization error” measure.
3) Signal Lag or “Latency”: because there is so much happening between the input and the output in digital circuits, all that processing time can result in a perceivable delay between striking the string and hearing the output. This delay affects the response and feel of guitar playing.
However, as long as the above losses are compensated for in the digital design with better buffers, processing, and memory, they disappear for human perception. Recent digital solutions channel music well enough that even John Mayer cannot tell the difference any more. So, if technical differences between analog and digital solutions don’t matter any more, why do analog at all? It is a good question, scary for analog monogamists, but also one that has already been factored into studio recording techniques for a long time now: most studio recording has ended up in a DAW (i.e., a Digital Audio Workstation) for many years. The signals probably went through various analog effects before reaching the DAW, but the actual end recording still goes to a computer these days. So, the reality is that modern studios actually use hybrid technological solutions and signal paths, usually analog to digital, and they probably will continue to do so for the foreseeable future. Therefore, for reproducing, recording, and storing the end result of music making, analog and digital differences don’t seem to matter any more.
Remaining Differences in Digital and Analog Effect Design
So far, we have only analyzed implications for recording music, or using a model of a recorded sound when playing live through a digital device (e.g., plugins). But we have not yet addressed how analog and digital differences affect the design of circuits and effects themselves, which I think is an interesting and neglected side of the debate. From a design perspective, there are still important remaining differences that highlight what makes each technology useful and special in my opinion.
Because analog effects by definition only deal with the pure source signal, they are restricted in the possible ways they can manipulate it by the physical limitations of electronic components used in their designs. The pure source is a voltage (and current, but mostly voltage in guitar pedals) from a guitar pickup, and that can only interact with discrete electrical components at first. Even digital solutions need to use an ADC (i.e., Analog Digital Converter) to start the translation process, so digital is always downstream of analog in some way. Far from being a bad thing, analog design limits are actually very creative, for it is these limitations which shape the sounds we know and love. For example, think of the sag caused by a big capacitor filling up again after being temporarily emptied by a transient from a strong hit of a string: we physically have to wait for the capacitor to fill up before the signal can be amplified properly again but the effect can feel satisfying to play.
Physical limitations also explain why analog effects tend to be simpler to use, usually with less features too, because it is more expensive in terms of part count, labour, and design complexity, to parametrize an aspect of the analog signal’s behaviour than it is compared to digital solutions. As an analog designer, you are forced to choose what is most important to you and then find space for it on your PCB (i.e., the electronic boards inside your pedals). Such choices necessitate care. A digital designer on the other hand can parametrize anything at any number for almost the same computational cost: once the signal has been translated to 0s and 1s and programmed, the difference between 10 parameters and 1 parameter is computationally negligible if these are targeting things like EQ.
Digital is capable of much more extreme sonic effect modifications because it is not limited to the physical properties of electronic components to process the signal. Digital translation allows so many different possible effects and gradations and combinations: time domain, frequency domain, every aspect of possible source signal modification. This is digital’s anarchic potential which I don’t think has even been properly explored yet, but it will be (especially with AI eroding the coding barrier) and the results will be fascinating I think, probably more interesting than digital just copying analog anyway, which is what it has largely done up to now.
Arms of the Analog Snowflake: Tolerance, Drift, and Biasing
Analog effects, such as transistor-based gain stages for example, are special because they need to be calibrated and biased individually: discrete electronic components exhibit variability (or “tolerance”) in their range of values which can subtly influence and individuate circuits. Today, biasing is commonly done with trim pots but many years ago you had to use fixed value resistors to get as close as you could to half the supply voltage for max headroom from your AC swing (i.e., VCC/2). This means that each circuit build was truly an individual because the bias would be slightly different and clipping would therefore be different in each one (e.g., in the case of rail clipping as happens in many fuzz circuits). Component values “drift” over time as well, meaning as the material ages and degrades, it affects the electrical properties controlling the analog signal flow: a 10K ohm resistor today might be 12.3K ohm in 20 years, and that can make an audible difference if part of a RC frequency filter for example.
It is hard for digital solutions to truly emulate this inherent individuality of component tolerance and age, especially when these differences are compounded by the part count in even the smallest most basic analog circuits. If every component’s value can wiggle 20% due to tolerance and drift, the schematic can say what it likes, but some builds of the analog circuit will sound subtly different. Normally, the most digital could do is model a single analog circuit build and then try to parametrize the individualizing properties of it. It can do this but that requires designing some sort of “error parametrization” to try to simulate some of the analog imperfections which begins to be a really funny use of the technology because at that point, you might as well just use analog.
Digital Glass with Analog Beer
John Mayer found his sound(s) with analog technology, and then was subsequently impressed by digital copying it and reproducing it. People still have to start at analog by default because that’s what a guitar pickup is. Even if younger generations go to digital for practical reasons, many of them will eventually get curious about analog technology. Analog effects will still be an important part of many tone-chasing journeys and we shouldn’t blame guitarists for wanting all the perceivable goodness of analog (through digital solutions) without the large physical footprint, price tags, mushrooming of possible failure modes in the signal chain, and pedals with fussy power supply requirements. This is a case of digital parasitizing the sonic qualities of analog and making them more usable, so I think of it more like a digital glass filled with delicious analog-sounding beer: in this context, the digital is only good because it sounds so analog. Therefore, analog is still winning.
Analog Glass with Digital Beer
Interestingly, there are opposite lesser-known cases where the glass is analog and the sound inside is actually more digital. Take a “Schmitt trigger” plus “Flip-Flop” combo for example. It’s a circuit combo block used in analog octave down effects (e.g., the MXR Blue Box uses a Flip-Flop) where the guitar AC signal is smashed into a square wave by the Schmitt trigger and then divided in two by the Flip-Flop. The Flip-Flop is the basic unit of digital memory and stores an off-on (0,1) value. This is another example that shows how silly the analog vs. digital culture war is: will knowing this nerdy detail about the digital heart of a classic analog circuit ruin the next time you hear it on Jimmy Page’s solo on Fool in the Rain? I sincerely hope not. So don’t let Neural DSP cut you off from the pleasure of listening to Analog Achilles do his stuff either.
The Future Musical Artifactual Economy
Analog technology itself has undergone many evolutionary shifts and fads, going from tubes, to transistors, to ICs (i.e., integrated circuits). When circuit designers moved on from one form of analog amplification to another, they did so for economic reasons as much as artistic and technical ones. Transistors were a lot cheaper and easier to use than tubes, so everyone redesigned the circuits they previously loved in tube form for transistor topologies (this was especially true in hi-fi audio design of the early to mid 60’s, so the shift largely predated the rise of pedals). Every time a shift like this happened, it wasn’t because designers in the old technology had run out of ideas, it was just that something new and more economically feasible came along that needed to be explored. This is why I like analog circuit design so much and why I am starting my own company that specializes in that niche (Antifōn Audio): antiquated analog technology is a reservoir of untapped future designs, like a prematurely abandoned goldmine with lots of gold left in it. I love deconstructing old shunt and series discrete feedback designs while retaining their aesthetically pleasing functions, and translating these hi-fi analog design techniques into guitar pedal circuits. The differences in the sounds of these “new-old” designs are valuable because I notice and appreciate the subtle variations in attack, texture, and frequency response, but if someone can’t tell the difference, it also doesn’t bother me -- I don’t feel the need to defend myself or evangelize. If digital copies one of my designs one day, that will mean it was a good design and hopefully I will have made a bit of money on it by then. This also seems to me to be a digital version of the same problem that analog guitar pedals (and basically all consumer electronics) already had: cloning (topologies) is legal, so why do analog monogamists find digital clones somehow more offensive than analog ones?
Digital solutions will find their place in the ecology of music making artifacts, and they will do so without killing analog technology, just as a forest contains vertebrates, invertebrates, fungi, and vascular plants: the equilibrium might change a little with the introduction of a new species or phylum, but the forest always rebalances itself in time.

